程序代写代做代考 Excel Microsoft Word – EEET2349-Project Proposal Marking Form_2017.docx
Microsoft Word – EEET2349-Project Proposal Marking Form_2017.docx
EEET2349 Project Marking Form – Project Proposal (25% of the total mark for the course)
Project Title
1
:
Name: Supervisor
:
ID:
Assessment criteria Mark Comments
1. Suitability2
Mark available Category
0 no‐show
3
1 marginal
2 average
3 above average
4 excellent
2. Statement of the design/
research problem
4
Mark available Category
0 no‐show
1 vague or superficial
2 clearly stated
3 clearly stated and articulated
3. Preliminary literature review5
Mark available Category
0 no‐show
1 marginal
2 acceptable
3 excellent
4. Design requirements/
performance criteria
Mark available Category
0 no‐show
1 vague or superficial
2 clearly stated
3 clearly stated and articulated
5. Design/research approach/
methodology/plan
6
Mark available Category
0 no‐show
1 questionable
2 acceptable
3 well thought out
6. Originality/novelty/innovation
Mark available Category
0 no‐show
1 maybe
2 yes
7. Clarity of presentation
Mark available Category
0 no‐show
1 unclear
2 satisfactory
1
Project student’s design/research project proposal is marked by academic supervisor in terms of its suitability for
an academic assessment of proponent’s specialised knowledge and skills at AQF level 9, and originality/novelty/
innovation [AQF13].
2
Suitability here refers to whether the proposal allows assessment of specialised knowledge and skills at AQF level 9.
3
“No‐show” means that the project student does not attempt and/or the work presented is irrelevant.
4
Three categories of engineering design projects are creative design leading to new and innovative products; variant
design to improve performance or to add new features to an existing system; and routine design using well
developed theory and practice for the design. Types of engineering design project may vary and include system
engineering and integration synthesizing subsystems into a larger system, experimental design to design
procedures and apparatus to determine characters of a given system, device, etc., analysis to analyse an existing
system for improvement, and research which is applied research based on existing technology and theory from
fundamental research to discover and/or create a new technology [FC08].
5
Literature and technology review relevant to project work includes fundamental concepts, principles, theories; in‐
depth specialised knowledge leading to the state‐of‐the‐art; benchmark technologies and engineering means; and
supporting evidence/materials for product requirements/needs.
6
The methodology and approach may be described using mathematical representations, system and or component
level diagrams, state diagram, flowchart, state machine, or physical diagram, etc., accompanied by a feasible plan
(e.g., using Gantt chart).
EEET2349 Project Marking Form – Project Proposal (25% of the total mark for the course)
8. Quality of references
Mark available Category
0 no‐show
1 Un‐refereed or questionable
2 refereed or standard
3 refereed/up to date/well selected
9. Overall performance
Mark available Category
0 no‐show
1 marginal
2 satisfactory
Total Mark
7
Supervisor’s overall comments:
Supervisor’s signature:
(not required if sent by email from RMIT address)
Date:
ADDITIONAL NOTES
AQF level 9 summary and learning outcomes criteria [AQF13]
Summary Graduates at this level will have specialised knowledge and skills for research,
and/or professional practice and/or further learning.
Knowledge Graduates at this level will have advanced and integrated understanding of a
complex body of knowledge in one or more disciplines or areas of practice.
Skills Graduates at this level will have expert, specialised cognitive and technical skills
in a body of knowledge or practice to independently:
• analyse critically, reflect on and synthesise complex information, problems,
concepts and theories;
• research and apply established theories to a body of knowledge or practice;
• interpret and transmit knowledge, skills and ideas to specialist and non‐
specialist audiences.
Application of
knowledge
and skills
Graduates at this level will apply knowledge and skills to demonstrate
autonomy, expert judgement, adaptability and responsibility as a practitioner
or learner.
References:
[AQF13] Australian Qualifications Framework Council, Australian Qualifications Framework, 2nd ed.,
Jan. 2013.
[FC08] R.M. Ford and C.S. Coulston, Design for Electrical and Computer Engineers, Theory,
Concepts, and Practice, McGraw‐Hill, 2008.
7
Total marks available are 25 for this assessment, and a full mark of 25 corresponds to 25% of the final assessment
marks for the course.
